Friday, October 23, 2026

Why not Both? - (Indigineous Mathematics - For Oct 15th)

I believe Dr. Doolittle brings a wealth of different knowledge and ideas to the conversation. I never knew about the star blanket, and it's an amazing example of how Indigenous peoples incorporated math into their tiling and stitching. Another interesting point is his claim that math is useful because we make it useful. We have indeed created a world where math is fundamental to our structures and technology. However, I have some issues with Dr. Doolittle's other arguments, such as his suggestion that math isn't particularly useful for examining nature. We know that math can be used to model bacteria, populations, and other natural phenomena. He also suggests that mathematics hasn't been practiced much in Indigenous cultures, but the mathematical thinking involved in tiling, stitching, and weaving seems to contradict this. 

My biggest disagreement is how he compares Indigenous and non-Indigenous knowledge. He talked about valuing all forms of knowledge, but some of his examples seem to place Indigenous knowledge about mathematical or scientific knowledge. I believe we should value both forms of knowledge. There is value in both knowing when things happen, and also knowing what to do when they happen. The examples Dr. Doolittle used were eclipses, the changing seasons, and tsunamis. Predicting eclipses allows us to prepare for and study them, while scientific tsunami monitoring can provide early warnings that complement traditional knowledge about recognizing natural warning signs.

Overall I enjoyed the knowledge and points of view Dr. Doolittle brought to the dialogue. I just wish his comparisons had been more balanced in their appreciation of different forms of knowledge. I believe we should recognize the value of different ways of knowing without diminishing one to appreciate the other.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Class Feeback on Blog Posts and Assessment - (Exit Slip - For Oct 15th)

I have fully written this piece, but I'm not sure I want to post it on my blog, where it can be viewed by the whole class. I would rathe...