Saturday, October 10, 2026

Building Self & Community - (Backsourcing & Building - For Oct 1st)

 

(Upon further reflection I kind of changed my mind. I think my argument is more that, who are we to define what production is, and I believe producing anything, even if it doesn't have physical value, brings the same sort of benefits for the people doing it. I don't have time to re-write my article, so unfortunately you must read my cringe...) 

I don't really think the question of the article is what if we make everything ourselves, but what if we make some things. Communities coming together and creating some of what each other needs. It's a great idea in theory, but I think it gets stuck at that point, theory. Farmers markets exist, local stores exist, there are events which host a whole array of different goods created locally, handcrafted. The real issues are desire, time, and demand. 

Desire, for I do not desire to make many a thing. I enjoy making something here and there, I enjoy sewing, but I have no desire at all to learn many a skill. Time, every skill we learn takes time, it takes time away from everything else we enjoy. Sure someone could learn to make something to become self-sufficient, but they might rather spend all their time singing, dancing, playing piano, hiking, camping, etc. I believe the pursuit of these skills is just as valuable for personal enjoyment and happiness as creating something with our hands. They are still creating no less, just the product of their creations isn't given a physical form. Then there are forms such as painting, poetry, cooking, etc, where they are given physical form, but they don't reduce the need of outsourcing products for our needs. I implore people to have hobbies, to spend their time doing the things that they love and make them happy, but I won't begin to try to delude people that the thing they spend their time on has to create something "useful." Then of course, demand. People need a variety of products, and sometimes the ones they need can't be sourced locally, or they have no desire for local products. Would you really want to source handcrafted rope for your boat or climbing lines? Personally I wouldn't, I want something that's industrial, something I can trust. This is just one small example of products that can't be artisan sourced. Desire is one of the biggest ones for me, I enjoy and like a great variety of stuff, but I always find myself browsing and not buying anything when I go through local handcrafted markets. The products I desire and consume just don't tend to be easily made, and if they are, I have more or a passion to make them myself (sewing). Of course there is one last important issue, money. If someone really takes the time to make an excellent product, it usually has an expensive price tag, and consumers like me can't afford it.  

So where does all of this leave us? I absolutely support the idea of individuals and communities creating products, but only a few will have the passion for it. I encourage everyone else to follow their passions, and to produce beautiful things with their time, even if those things are just memories or emotions. It would be wonderful if we could source more things locally, but I just don't see how it's currently feasible or desirable, as once upon a time we did produce everything locally, but there are reasons we moved away from that. So anyway, carry on, and produce on, if you can! 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Class Feeback on Blog Posts and Assessment - (Exit Slip - For Oct 15th)

I have fully written this piece, but I'm not sure I want to post it on my blog, where it can be viewed by the whole class. I would rathe...